Should I drop collision coverage from my auto insurance?

Written by Ryan Lowell on March 22, 2011 & Posted in Insurance

Don't drop the ball when dropping collision coverage.

Dear Ryan,

I am trying to save money on my car insurance, and my friends tell me to drop collision coverage since my car is "just about worthless." Granted, it isn't new anymore, but it is a far cry from worthless. How do you determine when it is time to drop collision coverage to save money?

Thomas R. Orlando, Florida

Hello Thomas,

The basic rule of thumb is if the actual cash value of your car, minus your deductible, is less than twelve times the annual cost of your collision coverage you should drop your coverage to save money. I have seen this rule stated as low as seven times your coverage, but twelve seems to be the most common number. Another common guideline is if the premium for the coverage is 10 percent or more of the car's value, you should drop the coverage.

On my vehicle, the collision coverage cost me $251 annually and I have a $500 deductible. Using the 12-times the cost of my coverage rule, I would theoretically drop my coverage if my vehicle was worth less than $2512 ($3012 - 500). Using the 10 percent guideline, I would drop the coverage at $2010 ($2510 - 500).

If I were not able to absorb a $2500 loss, I would not drop my coverage until the value of my car, less my deductible, was low enough that I could financially recover from the loss.

You also have to consider the probability of a claim. Collision coverage pays for damage to your auto when you are at fault. If you are a safe driver and don't feel you are at risk for a claim, you may want to drop your collision coverage sooner. If you have been averaging a collision claim every couple of years, you may want to hang on to your coverage a little longer because a policy without collision coverage might not be the cheapest insurance.

Ultimately, Thomas, only you can decide when it is the right time to drop your collision coverage to save money on auto insurance. Use the guidelines, but factor your financial situation and the probability of you filing a claim into your decision.


Featured Insurance Companies

Insurify™️ - Virginia Drivers Can Save Up to 50%

  • The easiest way to compare 20 real quotes from top brands
  • Prices starting from $29/mo
  • Trusted by more than 4 million drivers - 4.9 star reviews
  • As seen on Fox News, WSJ, Forbes, Fortune Magazine

Ask Our Expert

View All

Q. Will my policy pay off my car loan if my car is totaled?
A. An explanation of what happens if your car is totaled out when you still owe money on your car loan or lease. Read More

Q. Will car insurance cover my stolen personal items?
A. If someone steals personal items from your car, will car insurance cover those items? Read More


Required parameter not set.
Request a Quote for:

Recent Insurance Stories

View All
If my car is totaled will my loan be paid off?
An auto insurance expert fields a question from a consumer who wants to know if their insurance policy will pay off their car loan if their car is totaled out. Find out what happens with your car loan if your car is declared a total loss. I totaled Read More...
  • Are my personal items covered by car insurance?
  • Find out how an SR-22 certificate of financial responsibility relates to your car insurance policy.
  • Find out whose insurance pays if you lend out your car and a friend causes an accident.
  • What is uninsured motorist coverage and do you really need it?
  • Featured Insurance Companies

    Progressive Insurance - #1 Rated Website

    • Take advantage of E-sign, Safe Driver, Pay-in-full, Multi-Car and other Discounts
    • Fast, easy and reliable claims service available 24 hours a day
    • Bundle your auto and home policies for additional savings